The images
in the following program
are very sensitive
and may be
as disturbing to viewers
as they were to us.
However,
we have to show the truth
about cruelty to animals.
Personality’s been found
in a range of fish
and we’ve studied
rainbow trout, carp,
saber fish and stickleback
so there’s wide range
of fish that show these
personality differences.
Gracious viewers,
this is Stop Animal Cruelty
on Supreme Master
Television.
Today, June 8th is
World Oceans Day
as declared by
the United Nations.
This year’s theme is:
“Our Oceans: Opportunities
and Challenges.”
In honor of
this important occasion,
we focus on
the widespread,
savage treatment of
marine life, specifically
our bright fish friends
who have emotions,
are capable of feeling pain
and wish to live free
and in peace
just as any of us do.
Their will to live is
certainly obvious through
visual observation of
their desperate struggle
for life when caught.
They suffer immensely,
not only from suffocation
but some are crushed
to death after being
thrown onto fishing vessels
while others are still alive
when their throats
and bellies are cut open.
According to
the United Nations,
in 2005, commercial
fishing operations took
90 million tons of fish
from the oceans.
However this huge figure
does not even begin to
give one an idea
of the true scale
of death caused
by the fishing industry.
Sadly some still
hold the belief that
fish are lower level beings
incapable of
experiencing feelings.
But this is a complete myth
and the opposite is true.
While many people
have never stopped
to think about it,
fish are smart,
interesting animals
with their own
unique personalities.
Hundreds of studies
have shown
that fish are intelligent,
can use tools
and have impressive,
long-term memories
and sophisticated
social structures.
Fish can tell
what time of day it is and
can talk to one another
through sounds that are
inaudible to humans.
Research has also
clearly shown that fish
experience both physical
and emotional pain.
Their physical reaction
to trauma – thrashing,
grunting and rocking
in distress is obvious,
and once harmed
they will remember
what caused the pain
and actively avoid it.
So fishing, whether
for profit or for sport
cannot be considered
a harmless
or humane activity.
For people who oppose
cruelty to animals
the suffering
that fishing causes
should be a real concern.
Dr. Lynne Sneddon is
a British marine biologist
who is a senior lecturer
in animal behavior
and welfare
and a research fellow
in fish welfare
at the University
of Liverpool, UK
and the University
of Chester, UK.
She has conducted
detailed studies
on fish behavior
and intelligence.
There’s an old myth
that fish have
a three second memory.
Can you share with us
your latest work and
findings on fish memory
and personality?
I have colleagues
who’ve shown that
gold fish can remember
for three years,
not three seconds.
So, there is a lot of data
out there showing that
fish behavior and memory
is of quite long duration
and it’s really linked
to how long a fish lives.
So, short-lived fish
do tend to
have short memories.
So for example, stickleback
which lives for a year,
the longest memory
recorded was 22 days,
because why would you
remember for 10 years
if you only live for a year?
My work showed
that fish were able to
learn from each other
and alter their behavioral
reactions subsequently.
So that indicates that
they obtain information
just by observing
another fish and then
make behavioral decisions
based upon that.
One thing that
fish are really good at
are, is smelling,
and recent experiments
have shown that they can
actually recognize
their own smell and
can recognize themselves.
Now, self-recognition
is thought
to be a higher order
mental process, only seen
in dolphins and dogs,
but actually, that’s done
by sight, by mirror
recognition experiments.
Fish don’t really live in
such a visual world
and so they use smell
to recognize themselves,
and that’s showing that
fish are capable of a higher
mental order process.
India has the third largest
fishing industry
in the world and People
for the Ethical Treatment
of Animals India,
or PETA India, recently
released a detailed report
entitled “Assessment
of Animal Welfare
& Environmental Impact
of Indian Fisheries
& Aquaculture”
along with a brief film
of the same name.
Commercial fishing is
a big business,
and its methods are
as cruel as those that
are used in factory farms
or slaughterhouses.
Fish are impaled,
crushed, suffocated
and gutted all
while fully conscious.
The horrible cruelty
that fishers inflict on
hundreds of billions of fish
is completely unregulated.
Fishing boats may go after
certain species of fish,
but their hooks and nets
drag up thousands
of other marine animals
like sharks, dolphins,
sea turtles, birds, seals,
whales, and
other species of fish
who get tangled in nets.
These unwanted catches
are also known
as “bycatch” and
without a second thought
are forcefully
thrown back overboard.
The injured beings often
slowly bleed to death
in the water.
Scientists have found
that nearly 1,000
marine mammals –
dolphins, whales,
and porpoises –
die each day
after they are caught
in fishing nets.
When we return
we’ll continue examining
the brutality imposed
on marine life and discuss
the barbarous practice
of aquaculture.
Please stay tuned
to Supreme Master
Television.
This is the
Stop Animal Cruelty series
on Supreme Master
Television
with our program regarding
the merciless exploitation
of marine life
by the fishing industry
and others.
Aquaculture or fish farms
are inhumane
and dangerous, not only
for the innocent beings
imprisoned in
these heartless operations
but also for the humans
who consume
factory farmed fish.
Fish farmers raise
thousands of fish in ponds,
pools and concrete tanks.
Aqua farms are located
close to shorelines,
and fish in these farms
are packed into net
or mesh cages.
All fish farms are rife
with pollution, disease
and suffering.
According to investigators,
the ponds in some
government fish farms
were kept in such
an unhygienic condition
that they were no better
than drainage water, and
many fish who were forced
to live in dirty water
contracted skin diseases.
Fish were infested with
parasites and suffered
from other illnesses.
Many ponds were so dirty
that it was difficult to see
whether there were fish
in them.
Fish became stressed
as handlers carelessly
transferred them
from ponds to plastic bags
that it did not have
adequate water
and oxygen.
Fish that live in the oceans,
rivers and elsewhere
are severely affected
by the enormous amounts
of pollution and garbage
that humanity dumps into
water bodies every day.
People who consume fish
are taking into their systems
these very same
toxic substances in highly
concentrated amounts.
Fish live in water
that is so polluted,
you would never
dream of drinking it, but
you ingest this toxic brew;
bacteria, contaminants,
heavy metals and oil,
every time you eat fish.
Many studies have revealed
that fish often contain
unusually high levels
of mercury.
High levels of mercury,
which accumulates
in the environment
in fish flesh and
in the bodies of people
who eat fish,
contribute to birth defects
and other health problems.
And several studies
have demonstrated
lower mental acuity
among children of women
who consume fish
during their pregnancies.
As elaborated upon
in the PETA India report
“Assessment
of Animal Welfare
& Environmental Impact
of Indian Fisheries
& Aquaculture”
the fishing industry is
wiping out marine species
at a rapid rate
from the oceans with
absolutely no thought
given to the future
survival of sea life
or even of humanity.
Commercial fishing
and aquaculture
have an extremely
negative impact
on the environment.
Commercial fishing
destroys biodiversity,
as wide nets sweep up
the fish in their path,
they take coral habitats
with them.
Commercial fishers
have devastated
the ocean’s eco- system
to the extent that
some large fish populations
are only 10% as large as
they were in the 1950s.
According to one study,
the world’s oceans could
be empty of fish by 2048
because of overfishing,
loss of habitat,
climate change
and pollution.
Fish farms have caused
serious eutrophication
of water columns
and sediment
in enclosed coastal areas,
causing
the seabed environment
to become drastically
depleted of oxygen.
A 2005 United Nations
Food and Agriculture
Organization report
concluded the following:
One-quarter
of the world’s fish stocks
are overly exploited,
depleted or are recovering
from depletion.
They have endured
excessive fishing pressure,
which has reduced them
significantly.
About half of the stocks
are fully exploited.
They are being fished at
or close to their maximum
sustainable limits.
There is no room
for further expansion
of fishing activity.
Eighty-two varieties
of fresh water,
cold water, brackish
and marine water fish
are either endangered
or vulnerable.
Trawling ships
can be up to the size
of a football pitch
and may stay at sea
for six months at a time.
Trawling has been
compared to strip mining
given that the total
ecological destruction
it leaves behind.
It has been estimated
that the practice
has already caused
the extinction
of 10,000 marine species.
Scientific studies show
that fish that somehow
manage to escape
the trawling net
are so stressed
that 10 to 30 %
will die after the event,
with up to 70%
of herring perishing.
Bottom trawling is
among the most damaging
and unsustainable
fishing practices in India.
It involves
dragging huge heavy nets
along the sea floor.
The large metal plates
and rubber wheels that
are attached to these nets
move along the seabed and
crush nearly everything
in their path.
Deep water life forms
are profoundly affected
by this practice, taking
anywhere from decades
to hundreds of years
to recover;
if they recover at all.
It’s clear
that commercial fishing
and aquaculture cause
endless and
unspeakable suffering
to aquatic animals,
but what about so-called
“recreational fishing”
and keeping fish as pets?
Let’s hear from
Dr. Sneddon once again.
If you accept
that fish are capable of
pain and fear and stress,
you have to accept
that if you are
simply catching a fish
for your own enjoyment,
you are potentially
causing pain and fear
to that fish.
And it’s been proven that
the fish is very stressed,
they can suffer mortality
and that their
subsequent behavior
can be affected after
they’ve been released.
In terms of
living in a gold fish bowl,
I think that’s also wrong,
I think any animal,
providing it
with these static,
unchanging environments
would result in boredom
and frustration and
probably lead to ill health.
You couldn’t keep a dog
in the same air,
confined air
with no stimulation,
you couldn’t do that,
but yet we apply it to fish.
To commemorate
World Oceans Day,
let us take the opportunity
to begin taking
better care of the oceans
by adopting
the compassionate, noble,
organic vegan diet,
thus allowing
our sea animal friends
to not only
replenish themselves
but also to live forever
in tranquility.
Finally, we would like
to convey our gratitude
to Dr. Lynne Sneddon
and the People
for the Ethical Treatment
of Animals India
for helping to bringing
to the public’s attention
the alarming state of
our marine environments
and the urgent need
to preserve them.
For more details,
please visit
the following websites:
PETA India
www.PETAIndia.com
Lynne Sneddon
www.Liv.ac.uk/marinebiology
Thank you
for your company today
on Stop Animal Cruelty.
Coming up next is
Enlightening Entertainment
right after
Noteworthy News,
here on
Supreme Master Television.
Let us all lead
compassionate lifestyles
in harmony with nature.
Did you know that
in Croatia it’s against
the law to disturb a snake?
And that a Swiss law
stipulates that
every goldfish kept
must have a companion?
Increasingly,
all around the world,
comprehensive animal
welfare legislation is
being passed to safeguard
our animal friends.
I liked to represent
and to help minorities,
and animals are a weak
minority in society.
And on a personal level,
I was once deprived,
not allowed to speak
for 10 days
for medical reasons,
for health reasons, and
then I started to feel with
the animals and to listen
quite closely to
what animal experts
want to tell us.
Be sure to watch
“Protecting Our Brethren:
Animal Welfare Laws
From Around the World”
Saturday, June 12,
on Animal World:
Our Co-Inhabitants.